Today, we are doing a band saw versus scroll saw comparison. One big difference between the band saw and the scroll saw is that the band saw has a lot more power. The size of the blade, and the way it is built, makes the band saw ideal for any piece of wood thicker than 2 inches, and the thickness of the material the band saw can cut is really only limited by the distance between the work table and the horizontal arm.
The benefit of using a scroll saw vs. a band saw is that when you’re using the scroll saw on a tabletop, you have the ability to rotate it. For those who do woodworking and you’re trying to decide between a band saw vs. scroll saw for caricature carving, the scroll saw’s fine blades will allow you the get precise detail work you’re trying to achieve. Naturally, power tools are going to cost a decent amount of money, and it is going to be something you’ll need to consider when you are trying to decide between a scroll saw vs. band saw.
A Band Saw and a Scroll Saw may perform the same basic function of sawing but they are different tools with different uses. The Scroll saw is used for detail work to cut intricate patterns in the wood and give the material a final touch… A key difference between a Band saw and a Scroll saw is their design and how they operate: The Band saw uses a motor and wheels, usually two, to drive a continuous loop blade with teeth on one side around the wheels and it cuts in a downward motion. The Scroll saw uses a motor and an arm to move a very thin, needle-like blade in an up and down motion, similar to a jigsaw… Another important difference between a Band saw and a Scroll saw is their features and how they are used: Band saws are more powerful and can easily handle big projects.
Knowing that you need a scroll saw or a band saw is easy but knowing which one you need can be a little trickier. In contrast to scroll saws and other types of saws you might have in your arsenal, band saws are typically used for bigger woodworking projects and can handle much thicker material. A band saw has a worktable similar to the scroll saws, but it is open in the front and back letting you cut long pieces with no obstruction.
The blade is actually the biggest difference between a scroll saw and a band saw. Another major difference between these saws is that the throat on a band saw only refers to width. At first glance, a scroll saw and band saw look very similar.
metal vs wood bandsaw speed Related Question:
What speed should a metal bandsaw run at?
Bandsaw: Speeds. A common speed for the bandsaw is about one thousand feet per minute. Wood can effectively be cut at much higher speeds, up to and over five thousand feet per minute, but you should keep it slower because it’s safer.
What RPM should a bandsaw run at?
Bandsaws always use 1725 rpm. The 3450 rpm are way too fast. From contributor R: Depending on the size of the wheels bandsaw blade speeds can vary between 2000 SFPM to over 4500 SFPM.
What is the difference between a wood band saw and a metal band saw?
A metal cutting bandsaw is typically built more solidly than a saw designed for cutting wood, so there are no issues with the machine itself. As for the blade, the wood fibers could clog the metal blade’s teeth more quickly, and the blade will probably cut through the wood more slowly.
How do I increase the speed of my bandsaw?
Answer: Some models of bandsaws do provide the ability to alter the speed of the blade (usually expressed as FPM – feet per minute). The change of speed is usually accomplished by moving a drive belt to a secondary location on the pulley(s) of the drive pulley and motor pulley.
How much tension should a bandsaw blade be?
For carbon steel toothed blades (cutting blades) this is typically 15,000 to 25,000 PSI. Slitting type blades typically are tensioned in the range of 12,000 to 20,000 PSI. In general bandsaw blades are never tensioned past 35,000 psi.
How is bandsaw speed calculated?
The formula to determine S.F.P.M. is: Motor RPM multiplied by the Motor pulley diameter divided by the Driven pulley diameter times the Bandsaw wheel diameter times pi (3.1416) divided by 12 = S.F.P.M.
What speed does a circular saw run at?
It is clear that in the speed range from 1173 to 1500 rpm, the circular saw would easily be- come unstable and pose a hazard to the people working with it. Critical rotational speed theory of the circular saw has been a subject of many scientific publications.
How do you find the peripheral speed of a saw blade?
To calculate SFPM: (1) Multiply the diameter of the blade times Pi (3.1416) to get the circumference, then multiply circumference by RPM to get inches per minute and (2) divide the inches per minute calculation (from step 1) by 12 to get the feet per minute. Best results on most materials would be about 15,000 SFPM.
Can I put a metal cutting blade on my band saw?
Salem Straub. Typically if you run a metal blade on a wood bandsaw the excessive speed (2000 sfpm+) of the wood saw will knock the teeth off of your metal cutting blade in a hurry. You could make it work, but you would have to slow the blade drive wheel way down. Think 250 sfpm to 80 sfpm.
What is the difference between metal and wood?
In context|music|lang=en terms the difference between wood and metal. is that wood is (music) a woodwind instrument while metal is (music) characterized by strong, fast drum-beats and distorted guitars.
Can you cut wood with a bandsaw?
With the correct blade, a band saw can cut wood or metal, in either curves or straight lines. Blades come in a variety of widths and tooth counts. Narrower blades are good for tighter curves, while wider blades are better at straight cuts.
Can a bandsaw cut hardened steel?
Carbide band saw blades provide high wear resistance and toughness when cutting a variety of applications such as: case hardened steels, spring steels, high speed steels, nickel based alloys, case hardened steels, composite graphite, high nickel alloys, titanium, inconnel, and other exotic metals.
Why do bandsaws have 2 speeds?
The primary reason for speed adjustment on bandsaws is to accommodate different materials (mainly metal). That said, dropping the speed down for some operations can stretch the capabilities of an underpowered machine further.
When using the vertical band saw what blade speed would be appropriate for cutting mild steel?
Tool and rough steels require 40 to 60 surface feet per minute, mild steels 80 to 100 sfpm, and aluminium 200 sfpm+ (slower is fine — just not as efficient time-wise). For best results, use a recommended blade speed of under 200 feet per minute and preferably with coolant.
What causes bandsaw blade drift?
Drift is cause because the blade buckles under the load. You can see that by stretching a ribbon between 2 points and applying a pressure to one of the edges, it will turn sideway easily. A sharp blade and high blade speed will help a lot with that.